Triffin’s Dilemma vs Dollar Milkshake Theory

Triffin’s Dilemma is one of the most important yet often overlooked concepts in global finance. It highlights a serious conflict in the way the global monetary system works—especially when one nation’s currency, like the U.S. dollar, becomes the world’s primary reserve currency. To fully understand today’s global dollar debate, we also need to compare Triffin’s Dilemma with another modern theory: the Dollar Milkshake Theory.

What is Triffin’s Dilemma?

Triffin’s Dilemma was introduced by economist Robert Triffin in the 1960s. It describes a long-term problem for any country whose currency serves as the global reserve. In today’s world, that currency is the U.S. dollar.

Here’s the issue: To meet global demand for dollars, the U.S. must run trade deficits. This means it imports more than it exports, sending dollars abroad. While this helps provide liquidity for international trade, it slowly weakens the U.S. economy by increasing debt and lowering trust in the dollar.

Key point: Triffin’s Dilemma warns that long-term reliance on a single reserve currency can lead to instability, inflation, and eventually, a loss of global confidence in that currency.

Dollar Milkshake Theory

Brent Johnson’s Dollar Milkshake Theory offers a different view. It suggests the U.S. dollar will become stronger, not weaker—at least in the short term. Here’s why:

• Global central banks have printed huge amounts of money in recent years.
• Much of that capital flows into U.S. assets because the dollar is still considered safe.
• As a result, the U.S. “sucks up” global liquidity—like drinking a milkshake through a straw.

While Triffin’s Dilemma focuses on the long-term risks of deficits and dollar dependence, the Milkshake Theory highlights current dollar strength caused by global capital flows.

How Triffin’s Dilemma Affects the Global Economy

Triffin’s Dilemma shows that persistent U.S. trade deficits can become a problem over time. Here’s how:

• Too many dollars in circulation can lead to inflation.
• Other countries may lose faith in the dollar and seek alternatives.
• The global financial system becomes unstable if the U.S. can no longer sustain its deficits.

Eventually, this could result in a major shift in how the world conducts trade and holds currency reserves.

Policy Suggestions from Triffin’s Dilemma

Triffin proposed creating a new international monetary system. Instead of depending on one reserve currency, like the U.S. dollar, the world could use a basket of currencies or a new neutral asset. This would reduce the pressure on the U.S. and create a more balanced global system.

However, moving away from the dollar is not simple. The global economy is deeply connected to the dollar, and any major shift would require global cooperation and careful planning.

Dollar Milkshake Theory: Current Trends vs. Future Risks

While Triffin’s Dilemma focuses on long-term risk, the Dollar Milkshake Theory describes short-term strength:

• Investors continue buying U.S. bonds and stocks.
• The Federal Reserve’s interest rate policy helps attract foreign capital.
• Other countries, especially emerging markets, face rising debt costs as the dollar strengthens.

However, over time, these dollar inflows could turn into outflows if trust in the system declines—bringing Triffin’s Dilemma back into focus.

Triffin’s Dilemma and U.S. Policy Choices

U.S. policymakers face a difficult choice:

• Continue supporting the global dollar system by running deficits and supplying liquidity
• Or shift toward a more balanced system, possibly with shared reserve currencies

Each path comes with trade-offs. One offers short-term growth but long-term risk, while the other requires restructuring global finance.

Final Thoughts

In Forex Trading and macroeconomics, both Triffin’s Dilemma and the Dollar Milkshake Theory provide valuable insights. One highlights the long-term risks of a dollar-dominated system; the other explains the short-term strength of the U.S. economy.

As of now, the dollar continues to dominate global markets. But rising deficits, inflation risks, and global shifts may eventually push the system toward change.

Key takeaway: Understanding Triffin’s Dilemma is essential for investors, economists, and policymakers as they prepare for possible changes in the global financial system.

Stay ahead in Forex—debate, trade, and profit with us on Discord!

Click here to read our latest article: Pips, Politics and AI