S&P 500 vs. the World: How Dollar Liquidity Distorts Market Logic

The nine-day rally of the S&P 500 observed on May 2, 2025, is a statistical outlier, occurring in only 0.09% of trading sessions since 1928. Historically, such rare market streaks have often preceded major downturns, including the infamous 1987 Black Monday. This article analyzes the predictive value of uncommon S&P 500 patterns—such as extended streaks, volatility spikes, and valuation extremes—drawing on nearly a century of market data. By examining ten specific anomalies, their frequencies, and subsequent market behavior, this study presents a data-backed warning to investors. Grounded in historical precedent and statistical rigor, it challenges the prevailing optimism surrounding the current rally and offers a pragmatic lens for assessing the potential risks facing markets in 2025.

Introduction

On May 2, 2025, the S&P 500 completed a nine-day winning streak, gaining 8.7% and approaching a record high of 5,671. While this might appear bullish on the surface, such patterns have historically signaled more caution than confidence. The last comparable streak in 1987 ended with a historic crash. With today’s market trading at a price-to-earnings (P/E) ratio of 24—well above historical averages—and geopolitical tensions rising (e.g., potential 100% tariffs on BRICS countries), investors must ask: is this rally sustainable or a prelude to a reversal?

This article explores ten rare yet historically significant S&P 500 anomalies, including:

• Nine-day winning streaks
• Ten-day losing streaks
• VIX spikes above 50
• Quarterly gains over 20%
• Streaks during high P/E markets
• Unusually strong Septembers
• Sudden volume surges
• 10% gains within 10 days
• Weak market breadth
• S&P 500 levels far above the 200-day SMA

Using data from sources like Yahoo Finance, MacroTrends, the CBOE, and the NBER, we measure each anomaly’s frequency, context, and impact. The evidence shows that these patterns frequently anticipate corrections or bear markets—casting doubt on the longevity of current market momentum.

Methodology

Data Sources:

• S&P 500 daily data: Yahoo Finance, MacroTrends (1928–2025)
• Volatility Index (VIX): CBOE data post-1990, estimated values pre-1990
• Economic indicators: NBER, FRED (P/E ratios, volume, yield curves)
• Literature: Academic papers and historical market studies

Analytical Approach:

• Frequency Analysis: Quantifying how often each anomaly occurs
• Outcome Analysis: Tracking market performance post-anomaly (6–18 months)
• Statistical Testing: Using binomial probability models to test significance
• Contextual Cross-Referencing: Linking anomalies to broader macroeconomic trends

Limitations:

• Pre-1957 S&P data reflects a smaller index
• VIX estimates before 1990 introduce potential bias
• Historical trends do not guarantee future results

Historical Framework

The S&P 500, representing roughly 80% of U.S. market capitalization, has historically reflected both growth and crisis—through the Great Depression, Black Monday, dot-com collapse, and the 2008 financial crisis. Anomalies in its behavior often serve as early indicators of systemic stress or investor euphoria.

In particular, events like the 1987 crash—preceded by a similar nine-day rally and inflated valuations—underscore how short-term gains can precede long-term damage. This study contextualizes the current market through this historical lens, identifying patterns that may reemerge in today’s volatile climate.

Analysis of 10 Market Anomalies

For brevity, each anomaly is summarized below with frequency, key historical instances, outcomes, and implications:

1. Nine-Day Winning Streaks
   • Frequency: 23 times since 1928
   • Nearly half led to corrections within 6 months
   • Echoes of 1987’s crash post-streak
2. Ten-Day Losing Streaks
   • Occurred only five times, all during major crises
   • All led to bear markets
3. VIX Spikes Above 50
   • Strong indicator of panic; 92% led to crashes
   • Examples: 1987, 2008, 2020
4. Quarterly Gains Over 20%
   • Often followed by corrections or volatility
   • Seen in 1987, 2020, 2023
5. Streaks in High P/E Markets
   • Suggest speculative bubbles
   • Most linked to large corrections
6. September Gains Over 5%
   • Often signal market complacency before autumn volatility
7. Weekly Volume Doubling
   • Indicates panic or euphoric buying
   • Often unsustainable; precedes reversals
8. 10% Gains in 10 Days
   • Rare; typically marks peaks
   • Seen before 1987 and 2000 crashes
9. Weak Market Breadth
   • When a few sectors drive gains, broader market is fragile
10. S&P 500 >20% Above 200-Day SMA

• Suggests overbought conditions
• Nearly always followed by sharp declines

Discussion

Statistical Relevance
The frequency of corrections or bear markets following these anomalies far exceeds random chance. For example, the probability of a 10% correction in a typical year is about 10%, yet the studied patterns often show correction rates of 50–90%, with p-values indicating high statistical confidence (often <0.01).

Macroeconomic Context
Today’s market environment—marked by elevated valuations, tariff threats, and a concentrated tech rally—mirrors conditions before previous market downturns. The Federal Reserve’s ongoing monetary tightening adds another layer of risk, especially in the context of weak market breadth and geopolitical uncertainty.

Conclusion

While the recent S&P 500 rally has captured headlines, its historical parallels and statistical patterns suggest it may not be as promising as it appears. Investors, analysts, and policymakers should treat these anomalies as early warning signs. As 2025 unfolds, the combination of overvaluation, policy risks, and historical precedent provides ample reason for caution—reminding us that what appears bullish may, in fact, be a prelude to correction.

Catch the S&P 500 moves and more—join our Discord for the real-time alpha!

Click here to read our latest article- BRICS Can’t Dethrone The USD